Why Trial Experience Still Matters

After enough years in court, you begin to realize that a trial isn't really about lawyers. It's about people who have reached a point where they need someone else to hear their story.

Most disputes never need a courtroom, and that's how it should be. But every so often, a case comes along where a settlement offer isn't justice — it's just the cheapest way to make a problem disappear. When that happens, the courtroom remains one of the few places where an ordinary person can stand across from a company or an insurer and be heard on equal footing. A civil jury trial doesn't care who has more lawyers in the room. It cares whether the story is true and whether it was told well enough to understand.

That kind of equality is worth protecting — and it depends on lawyers who are actually prepared to use it.

Plenty of firms advertise trial experience. Far fewer attorneys prepare cases to go to trial as a matter of course. The difference shows up in the details: how a deposition is taken, how a medical record gets read, how an exhibit is built so twelve strangers can understand something a doctor spent a decade learning. It shows up in whether the other side believes you'll actually walk into a courtroom if they don't take the case seriously. That kind of courtroom advocacy isn't about volume or aggression. The best trial lawyers I know are usually the calm ones — the ones who prepare so thoroughly they never need to raise their voice. Preparation is what lets you be direct with opposing counsel instead of adversarial toward them.

A few weeks ago, I was invited to join the American Board of Trial Advocates.

ABOTA membership isn't something you apply for — it's earned through invitation, based on recommendations from lawyers who've actually stood across from you in a courtroom, including many who represent insurance companies and corporations rather than plaintiffs. That's part of what makes it different from an award. It's peer recognition from people who've watched you work, sometimes from the opposite side of the same case. ABOTA's founding purpose has always been the preservation of the civil jury trial — the constitutional right of ordinary citizens to decide disputes between other citizens, a right that has quietly eroded for decades as fewer cases ever reach a jury. Members are expected to hold two things at once: fight hard for clients, and do it with the professionalism and civility that keeps the system itself worth preserving.

If I'm honest about what the invitation means to me, it isn't the letters after my name. It's a reminder to look at my own case files the way the trial lawyers who recommended me would look at them — whether they're as prepared as they should be, and whether I'm holding myself to the standard I'd want if I were the one waiting to find out whether the system would work for me.

That question is the whole job. The people who come to Bennett Legal aren't looking for a headline. They're dealing with a catastrophic injury or wrongful death that shouldn't have happened, a solar contract or lending agreement built to confuse them, or an arbitration clause they didn't know they'd signed. What they need is an experienced trial lawyer who will actually prepare their case, actually listen, and actually be willing to try it if that's what fairness requires — whether the matter resolves in months or takes years to reach a courtroom.

ABOTA is a good reminder of that standard. But the standard was always the point, long before the invitation and long after it. The best trial attorneys aren't defined by recognition. They're defined by the responsibility they carry every time they stand up for someone who needs to be heard.

Charles A. Bennett is a trial lawyer in Dallas and an ABOTA member at Bennett Legal, where he has spent decades preparing cases for court on behalf of injury victims, consumers, and families across Texas.

This article is for general informational purposes and is not legal advice. Past results do not guarantee similar outcomes in future matters.

Contact Bennett Legal today →